Sunday, June 7, 2015

Painting the Vietnam War, Part 1

Now that Mrs. History PhD seems to have been bitten by the Flames of War bug, she has asked for a bit of general advice on painting vehicles and troops for the Vietnam War. I believe she's interested in those little nuances that show realism and a familiarity with the timeframe. That being the case, I imagine my observations may be generally helpful to others too, or so I flatter myself to believe.

I'm not going to get into the politics of the war and whether it was right or wrong. The real world is never that clear cut; not now and not 50 years ago. Whatever the morality of the war was (and is), it's germane here only in so far as it does to some extent affect how miniatures are depicted. More on that in Part 2. 

If you already know the basics, please forgive me if this first part is a brief history lesson to bring any newcomers up to speed. For a number of years, I taught a 400/500-level senior undergrad/graduate class entitled "The Vietnam Quagmire". If you remember the Vietnam War clearly, as I do (the latter part), you can skip ahead to Part 2. 

Although it was Franklin Roosevelt who began America's interest in Vietnam by supplying the precursor of the Vietminh in their war of attrition against the Japanese, it was Harry Truman who first sent US "advisors" to Indochina in 1950 and supplied the French so that they could hold on to their colony. Dwight Eisenhower escalated the numbers of US military advisors in the new Republic of Vietnam in 1956, along with supplying a large amount of financial aid and military equipment. 

Although Eisenhower and then John F. Kennedy increased the involvement and numbers of US advisors (to 23,000), the "war" as it is now popularly perceived didn't begin until early 1965, when Lyndon Johnson, in response to the Tonkin Gulf Incident, increased American forces in South Vietnam, as well as drastically changing the nature of the war, by sending 5000 Marines ashore at Da Nang. 
US Forces continued to increase until January 1969, when there were 550,000 in South Vietnam and large numbers in Thailand and aboard ship in Southeast Asian waters, as well as US troops in The Philippines, Guam, and Okinawa in support roles. 

As wargamers, we can break the war down into five distinct phases:
1) Advisors: 1961 through early-1965, when US troops mainly guarded the airbases they used and ARVN troops did most of the fighting in the field, accompanied by small numbers of US advisors. 
2) Escalation: mid-1965 through the end of 1968, when US troops took over the bulk of the fighting in the field and there was still optimism that the war could be ended successfully.
3) Disillusionment: 1969 through mid-1970, when US troops and the American public both realized that there was no successful end to the war in sight.
4) Vietnamization and withdrawal: late-1970 through mid-1973, when the US handed the prosecution of the war back to the South Vietnamese. US troops were (mostly) withdrawn and those that remained return to an advisory and training role. 
5) Final Collapse: late-1973 through April 1975, the US washed its hands of the whole situation and walked away, cutting off all military aid to South Vietnam, which then rapidly disintegrated under invasion from the North. 

Obviously, all of the above is in very broad strokes, as the Vietnam War is too huge, too long, too convoluted, too divisive, and still too provocative of very strong emotions even 40 years later, to be able to do any justice to the subject on a little-read hobby blog. 

As an aside, as you read through all of the above, I hope it will all sound very familiar to you, given that you've heard it all again over the last 14 years and we're again in Phase 4. 
  
Each of the war's phases saw changes in attitude among US, Allied, and ARVN troops in the field, which in turn influenced the appearance of uniforms and vehicles and how we depict them on the tabletop. Part 2 of this post will begin discussing those changes. Stay tuned!


9 comments:

  1. And the NVA are the Care Bears compared to IS...

    ReplyDelete
  2. Vietminh war of attrition against the Japanese? Ok... just a bit wondering if Archimedes Patti is not taken too seriously.... more on point things... also the PAVN was there from the start IS is a new phenomena that was not there during the US presence in Iraq (and no you cannot compare Vietnam to Iraq they are orange and apples, but yes foreign interventions seems to have similar stages).

    I would break the Advisory part in two: 1959-1962 when the effort was really small and US troops were not even guarding airbases and 1963-65 when first the Air Commandoes show up and then the first regular USAF units appeared and there were more advisors. I found the two phases quite different from both a wargaming and historical viewpoint. By the way... has miss History PhD made aware of the scellent Charlie Does not Surf from TFL? Better fun and more realism than FoW Vietnam but you can play with the same toys.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, the advisory fees can be broken down, but I was trying to be brief because it's too long to go into for just a hobby blog. Mrs History PhD seems to intend to use CDS with FOW miniatures

      Delete
  3. being short... no one will ever accuse me of that... (last time I started a short article supposed to not be longer than 3k words I ended with 12k...). Well great news that Miss History PhD knew about CDS, the first Vietnam rules that ever satisfied me... by the way I think that for Riverine Actions 6mm and 3mm are even better suited.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree on the 6mm river war. I have a whole collection of river craft, IF I ever get them painted

      Delete
  4. you are not alone... but have you seen these: https://www.shapeways.com/product/EW8DBHQGC/1-600-vietnam-riverine?li=user-profile&optionId=3187982

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have. Shapeways has a whole load of 1/600 riverine stuff. 1/300 too. But mostly too pricey for me

      Delete
  5. I keep fighting the urge to get into 1/600 Riverine, but it's a fight I'm losing.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I really do need to make more of an effort with the large 1/285 riverine pile I have waiting.

      Delete